The City of Alpena has decided to remove a beautiful, large, ancient maple tree on South 2nd Avenue because of a complaint they received claiming that its roots are affecting a sewer system. The Department of Public Works representative says that they have now designated it as a “hazard,” not only for the root problem but also because its large trunk has damaged the sidewalk and street curb. Finally, she has determined, just by looking at it, that this tree is dying.

After decades, this now “dying” tree is still sending out roots invading sewer systems? The representative can’t even say for certain that this tree is the problem. There are six other trees within 50 feet of either side of it. The curb shows no damage. As for the sidewalk, why didn’t the city adjust its placement during its mandatory sidewalk installation program 20 years ago?

In my opinion this tree looks healthy for its age, more healthy than half the trees at Starlite Beach. I ask the city to reconsider its decision and let this tree remain standing.

SUZANNE KELLY,

Alpena