Breaking News
Editorials and columns

Line 5 reroute in Wisconsin is a clown show

By Greg Awtry 5 min read
Awtry

When a federal court ruled that Enbridge and their Line 5 oil pipeline had been trespassing on Indian land in Wisconsin since 2013, Enbridge agreed to build around it, and it has been nothing but a clown show ever since. If Enbridge can't build a 41 mile-long oil pipeline around the Bad River Indian Reservation without dozens of violations, spills, and aquifer breaches, why would Michiganders ever consider letting them build a twenty-foot wide tunnel 370 feet below the Straits of Mackinac? Jeffrey Insko, a professor at Oakland University in Rochester Hills, Michigan has studied Line 5 for years, writes, “On October 13, the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources notified Enbridge of a whole litany of permit violations. The list is long and reflects the same slapdash, haphazard, thoughtless construction practices." Here are just a few on the list. On June 27, an inadvertent release of drilling fluid entered Vaughn Creek. On July 13, two separate inadvertent releases of drilling fluid entered Vaughn Creek and wetlands. On Sept. 9 Enbridge engaged in land-disturbing construction activity outside of the permitted construction site. On 9/10/2026, it was observed that areas of bedrock were not being backfilled in accordance with Enbridge's Environmental Construction Plan. On Sept. 25, an inadvertent release occurred within a wetland near the Deer Creek.

Then this: “Construction crews ‘breached an aquifer’ near the Marengo River. The company has faced similar regulatory action in neighboring states, paying roughly $13.8 million in total settlements to the MDNR for a series of four aquifer breaches along its Line 3 pipeline route.”

Then the big one! On Aug. 25: "Rupture Violations of Air Management when a Line 5 release of over 1.3 million gallons of natural gas vaporized and dispersed into the atmosphere. Nearby rural homes and residents were temporarily evacuated, power was shut off to the immediate area, a no-fly zone was set up. Enbridge said that approximately 4,275 tons of impacted soil had been removed. That clean-up continues to try and get the cancer-causing benzene out of the land and water.”

Finally, seeing enough of Enbridge's inability to follow agreements and laws, the WDNR issued an Official Notice of Violation on October 13, 2026, alleging “Enbridge Energy committed 34 violations during the construction of the Line 5 pipeline reroute between late March and September 2026, including, “Unpermitted construction: Building a temporary bypass without a permit., 18 instances of unauthorized impacts or permit breaches affecting state wetlands and waterways, nine violations of erosion and sediment control, along with other environmental violations of state laws."

Don't think this is just bad luck. According to "Violations Tracker" over the last 26 years, Enbridge has averaged one environmental violations every three months, resulting in penalties nearing $300 million dollars.

Now this mayhem is happening on the ground. One can only imagine all this happening 370 feet below the surface of the Straits of Mackinac. Of course, Enbridge says it will drill through solid bedrock and that no methane gas is present in the groundwater, but when they finally released their geotechnical report, it revealed instead of solid bedrock as originally planned, the data indicated the tunnel path would encounter poor bedrock as well as soft silts and clays, creating a challenging tunneling condition. The report also noted high water pressure, not enough borehole data across the 4-mile span, and natural toxic gas (methane) in the groundwater that had not been accounted for in the original design.

And just this week the Milwaukee Journal published a story basically saying the state of Wisconsin relied too heavily on Enbridge's own studies and assumptions in advancing the project, instead of conducting their own, implying you can't believe everything Enbridge reports. They add, "Even with monitors on site, problems have piled up. From late March through late September, Enbridge averaged one alleged violation about every five days."

And there is the lesson to be learned. Thank you, Wisconsin, for showing Michigan to not ever to rely on what Enbridge says, but what it does. We are the Great Lake State and it falls on every Michigander to preserve and protect them. Over 800,000 Michigan jobs are directly tied to the Great Lakes. More than half of us rely on Lake Michigan or Lake Huron for drinking water.

There are alternatives to building that tunnel, but Enbridge won't tell us those, unless it is using scare tactics to tell us of thousands and thousands of trucks crossing the bridge. Adding a 4-mile tunnel to a 645-mile pipeline still leaves us with 641 miles of 73-year-old pipe that was built to last only 50 years, and it leaks, a lot, over 30 spills and over a million gallons spilled. And being 23 years past its lifetime expectancy, well, you figure it out.

There are times when we have to measure the risk versus the reward, and this is that time. The risks are far too great, not only for us, but for the generations of Michiganders to come that are counting on us leaving the Great Lakes better than what was left to us.

Would you hire Enbridge to build a pipeline on your land? Let me know at gregawtry@awtry.com.

Starting at /week.