Trending
ALPENA -- Shaun Lozen, 46, had a hearing on Monday in the 26th Circuit Court, his second hearing since being bound over from the 88th District Court after preliminary examination.
Lozen is charged with felonies of two counts of assault with intent to murder, five counts of assault with intent to do great bodily harm less than murder - strangulation, and one count of interfering with electronic communications. He is also charged with misdemeanors of one count of domestic violence - aggravated and four counts of domestic violence.
During his preliminary examination in August, it was alleged that Lozen had been in a relationship with the alleged victim for about five years. The alleged victim testified to a number of alleged physical assaults, including strangulation, that occurred over the course of their relationship.
The News does not name victims of alleged domestic violence.
At Lozen's last hearing, Alpena County Assistant Prosecuting Attorney Alyssa Miller and Lozen's defense attorneys Deanna Kelley and David Kramer discussed a stipulation to search the alleged victim's phone.
The stipulation asked for the phone to be searched for all communications between the alleged victim and Lozen including photographs of the two and all phone recordings, all photographs of the alleged victim’s injuries, all communications between the alleged victim and police personnel regarding the investigation, and all communications between the alleged victim and three women that she allegedly messaged to warn them about Lozen.
Since that hearing, Lozen has obtained new counsel, Defense Attorney John Tosto. Tosto is based in Flint.
Tosto filed a motion for the return of seized property and a motion to receive a digital video copy of the preliminary examination.
Miller said that except for one cell phone that has evidentiary value, everything else is available to be returned to the defendant.
Tosto said it is his understanding that the phone has already been dumped by the prosecution, meaning that data has been extracted, and he would ask that the phone be returned as well.
"How can I return a phone when it is part of the evidentiary value of the case," Judge Ed Black asked.
"I understand Judge, that's our request," Tosto responded.
Whether the defense would be able to receive the phone back would depend on whether they are willing to sign a waiver, or there could be issues down the road with collecting evidence.
If the phone were to be returned, it could cause issues for the prosecution.
As for the second motion, Black said that the 88th District Court's procedure is to provide transcripts, not a video.
"That would be contrary to what the district court's policy is," Black said.
He said there is an option to come to the district court to view the video.
Tosto said he didn't know that was an option.
"It would be very beneficial for us to view the exam hearing in conjunction with the transcript, which we've already been provided," Tosto said.
He said it is useful in analyzing the credibility of the alleged victim and when preparing for a potential resolution or trial.
Black said that his understanding from prior counsel is that the case is "destined for trial." He denied the motion without prejudice to receive a digital video copy, saying he needed to do more research with regard to the district court's policy.
After further discussion, Black changed his order to provisionally grant Tosto the authority to attain a copy of the preliminary examination video, with the opportunity for Black to first contact district court to discuss why that policy is in place. The Court will have seven days to reach out to district court to verify the policy. If the video is provided to counsel, it can only remain in the custody of counsel and shall not be provided to anyone else.
Currently the alleged victim's phone is expected to be dumped by the Computer Crime Unit (CCU). Miller said the phone was dropped off with the Alpena Police on Nov. 5 and will be transported to the lab the next time an officer drives evidence there.
Lozen's next hearing will be at 1:15 p.m. on Feb. 16 in the 26th Circuit Court.
Reagan Voetberg can be reached at 989-358-5683 or rvoetberg@thealpenanews.com.